The island premium
The island premium: why sourcing a film set costs more in Newfoundland
Anything a Newfoundland set can't find on the island comes by truck and ferry, a 6 to 7 hour crossing plus up to 905 km of highway, and then it has to go back. The places that handle it best, from New Zealand to Northern Ireland, make and buy more of what a set needs close to home.
In Toronto or Vancouver, a missing chair is a drive across town to a prop house. In St. John's, anything that isn't already on the island rides a truck onto a ferry, crosses the Cabot Strait, and then has to make the same trip home when the shoot wraps. That gap in time, money and risk is the island premium.
What the island premium costs a Newfoundland set
Here's what a mainland order goes through before it reaches a St. John's set:
| Step | What it takes | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Ferry, North Sydney to Port aux Basques | usually 6 to 7 hours | Marine Atlantic |
| Ferry, North Sydney to Argentia | about 16 hours | Marine Atlantic |
| Highway, Port aux Basques to St. John's | 905 km, about 11 hours | Destination St. John's |
| Truck and trailer (72 ft) with driver, ferry round trip | about $1,400 | Atlantic Business Magazine |
| Share of goods that reach the island on the ferry | nearly 65% of all goods, 90% of perishables | Federal release, via Atlantic Business Magazine |
Argentia is only 131 km from St. John's, but that crossing is more than twice as long. Either way, a rental ships twice: out to the set and back to the mainland.
Then there's the weather. Winter storms cancel sailings, and Marine Atlantic has said a changing climate is bringing more of those disruptions (CBC News). Its own spokesperson put the ferry's share lower than the federal figure, at about half of all goods and 70 per cent of fresh produce. Either way, most of what isn't made here comes over on that boat.
For a set decorator, that adds up to three costs:
- Time. A piece from a mainland prop house needs a truck, a ferry booking and a clear forecast, plus the same again to send it back.
- Money. Freight both ways sits on top of the rental. One truck's ferry round trip alone runs about $1,400.
- Risk. One cancelled sailing can push a delivery past its shoot day.
How other islands and remote shoots handle it
The premium isn't unique to Newfoundland. Here's how four other places dealt with it.
Hawaii: the premium can move the shoot
Apple TV+'s Chief of War is set in Hawaii, but it spent only a month filming there and was mostly shot in New Zealand (RNZ). RNZ reported that productions in Hawaii often fly in cast, crew and equipment from the continental US, and compete with tourists for expensive rooms. Hawaii's rebate is also capped at US$50 million a year. When most of a set has to be brought in, the premium shows up in the budget, and producers go where it's smaller.
New Zealand: make it locally
For The Fellowship of the Ring, Wētā Workshop, based in Wellington, says it made tens of thousands of pieces, from armour and weapons to prosthetics and miniatures, for a film shot across New Zealand (Wētā Workshop). Instead of shipping a world in, the production had it made close to where it was filming.
Northern Ireland: local makers become suppliers
On Game of Thrones, local makers got work too. Steensons, a jeweller in the village of Glenarm, made costume props for the show, including brooches, crowns and belt pieces, and worked with HBO from the first season (Ballymena Times). Productions buy from local makers when they know those makers exist.
Tasmania: paying productions to spend locally
In May 2024, Tasmania launched a $1 million Island Screen Incentive: a grant of 10 per cent of what a production spends on Tasmanian goods and services, up to $500,000 (Premier of Tasmania). The island's government treats local spending as the prize worth paying for.
What it means for Newfoundland
The stakes are real here. Newfoundland and Labrador passed $1 billion in film and TV production spending in 2025, and 2024 alone topped $87 million and supported nearly 1,500 full-time jobs (Government of Newfoundland and Labrador). More shoots means more pull lists, and more pieces that either ride the ferry or don't.
The cheapest piece is the one already on the island. Talking about Son of a Critch, which is set in St. John's, Mark Critch said "a lot of my family's furniture is on set" (The Canadian Press). Newfoundland homes, sheds, shops and studios hold exactly the kind of things a period set asks for. The hard part has been finding them in time.
Our view: Newfoundland can't shorten the Cabot Strait, but every lamp, kitchen table or dory a crew finds here is one that never needs a ferry booking. Hawaii shows what happens when most of a set has to be brought in. New Zealand, Northern Ireland and Tasmania show the other way: grow local suppliers, and make local pieces easy to find and pay for. That's what NewfoundValue is for: props, set dressing and locations from Newfoundland owners, shops and makers, rented by the week, with one request for the whole pull list. If it isn't listed, we'll look for it. And if you have pieces a set could use, list them free.
Quick answers
What is the island premium for a film production?
It's the extra time, money and risk of bringing in anything an island doesn't have, and then sending it back. In Newfoundland, that means a truck and a ferry from the mainland, both ways.
How long does it take to get props from the mainland to St. John's?
The ferry from North Sydney to Port aux Basques usually takes 6 to 7 hours, then it's 905 km and about 11 hours by road to St. John's. The Argentia crossing lands 131 km from the city but takes about 16 hours (Marine Atlantic, Marine Atlantic on Argentia, Destination St. John's). Add booking, loading and the weather.
How do productions on islands keep sourcing costs down?
They make, buy and rent close to home. For The Lord of the Rings, Wellington's Wētā Workshop made tens of thousands of pieces for a shoot across New Zealand; Game of Thrones bought costume props from a Northern Ireland jeweller; and Tasmania pays productions back 10 per cent of what they spend on local goods and services.
Can a film crew rent props locally in Newfoundland?
Yes. NewfoundValue lists props, set dressing and filming locations from Newfoundland owners, shops and makers, rented by the week with one request for the whole pull list. If something isn't listed, we look for it.
Sources
- Marine Atlantic: Night crossing or day crossing? (2014): the Port aux Basques crossing is usually 6 to 7 hours
- Marine Atlantic: Length of crossings, why aren't they all the same? (2013): about 16 hours to Argentia; 5 to 7 hours on average to Port aux Basques
- Destination St. John's: Plan your trip: 905 km and about 11 hours from Port aux Basques; Argentia 131 km from St. John's
- Atlantic Business Magazine: Ferry rate cuts fail to reduce N.L.'s commercial shipping costs (August 5, 2025): about $1,400 truck round trip; nearly 65% of goods and 90% of perishables, per a federal release
- CBC News: Climate change behind ferry disruptions and shipping delays, Marine Atlantic says: storm cancellations; about half of all goods and 70% of fresh produce, per Marine Atlantic
- Government of Newfoundland and Labrador: $1 billion milestone in film and television (September 10, 2025): over $1 billion since the film agency began; over $87 million and nearly 1,500 full-time jobs in 2024
- RNZ: A Hawaiian epic made in NZ, why Chief of War wasn't filmed in its star's homeland: a month in Hawaii, mostly shot in New Zealand; flown-in crew and gear; US$50 million rebate cap
- Wētā Workshop: How we made it, The Fellowship of the Ring: tens of thousands of pieces made for the film
- Wētā Workshop: Lord of the Rings tour: the workshop's Wellington address
- Ballymena Times: Game of Thrones is fantasy come true for local jeweller: Steensons of Glenarm made costume props for the show
- Premier of Tasmania: Island Screen Incentive (May 18, 2024): $1 million program; 10% of local spend, up to $500,000
- The Canadian Press: Mark Critch on Son of a Critch (January 3, 2023): his family's furniture on set