Film and the local economy
Did The Lord of the Rings really boost tourism in New Zealand?
Partly. A peer-reviewed study found the original trilogy had no clear effect on arrivals. The Hobbit films, backed by national marketing, added about 214,811 visitors in 2013 and 2014.
Yes, but not the way the legend tells it. A peer-reviewed study found the original Lord of the Rings films had no significant effect on visitor arrivals. The Hobbit trilogy, backed by a national marketing push, added an estimated 214,811 visitors in 2013 and 2014 (Li and others, Tourism Management). The lasting winner was one farm near Matamata, now the Hobbiton Movie Set.
Middle-earth tourism by the numbers
| What | Figure | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Effect of The Lord of the Rings films on arrivals | No significant effect found | Li and others |
| Extra visitors from The Hobbit trilogy, 2013 and 2014 | 214,811 | Li and others |
| Extra tourist receipts from The Hobbit, 2013 and 2014 | US$771.8 million | Li and others |
| Holiday visitors who said The Hobbit was a factor, late 2013 | 14% | Tourism New Zealand, 2014 |
| Hobbiton visitors expected, 2024 season | 570,000 | Cambridge News, 2024 |
| Extra public money to keep The Hobbit in New Zealand, 2010 | NZ$33.5 million more in subsidies | RNZ, 2010 |
| New Zealand rebate for Amazon's series before it left | US$92 million | CBC News, 2021 |
The case studies
The Lord of the Rings, 2001 to 2003: the legend and the data
New Zealand is the textbook case for film tourism. Media reports once claimed the trilogy lifted arrivals by up to 50%. A team of tourism researchers tested that with arrival data and an economic model of the whole country (Li and others).
Their finding was blunt. For late 2001 to late 2004, the films showed no significant effect on arrivals from any market. The authors say the big claims lacked rigorous support.
That doesn't mean the films did nothing. It means the visitor boom of those years can't be pinned on them with confidence.
The Hobbit, 2012 to 2014: marketing made the difference
The second trilogy is where the numbers show up. Tourism New Zealand ran a "100% Middle-earth" campaign around the release. In late 2013, 14% of holiday visitors said The Hobbit helped them choose the country (Tourism New Zealand, March 2014). That share was 21% for Germans, 19% for Americans and 17% for Chinese visitors.
The Li study estimated the trilogy added 214,811 visitors over 2013 and 2014. China (64,337) and the UK (48,467) gained the most. Extra tourist spending came to about US$771.8 million, and New Zealand households gained about US$186 million in welfare (Li and others).
There was a cost inside the economy too. Output fell 1.35% in primary industries and 0.66% in secondary industries, as workers and capital moved toward tourism. The authors credit stronger, film-linked marketing for the gap between the two trilogies.
A 2017 NZIER report for the New Zealand Film Commission put those gains in local dollars. It came to about $1.11 billion in visitor spending (NZIER, 2017).
Hobbiton and Matamata: one farm, one district
The Hobbiton set sits on 5 hectares of a 500-hectare sheep and beef farm (NZ Herald, December 2023). Tours began in 2002, after filming wrapped. The set was rebuilt in permanent materials in 2010 for The Hobbit (Cambridge News, June 2024).
Today it has 44 permanent hobbit holes. Guinness World Records lists it as the largest film set (Hobbiton Movie Set release, April 2025). In 2024 the business expected 570,000 visitors, up from 530,000 the season before. About 85% come from overseas, and it employs about 275 people (Cambridge News).
The district felt it. NZIER found international visitor spending in Matamata-Piako rose from $9 million to $45 million by 2015 (NZIER). Spending on cultural activities there went from about $1 million in 2009 to about $26 million. The report dates the $9 million starting point to 2009 in one place and 2010 in another.
The risk showed in the pandemic. With borders shut, the attraction laid off 241 staff and dropped to 26 overnight (Cambridge News).
The price: subsidies, a rushed law and a series that left
Keeping The Hobbit in New Zealand took a deal. In October 2010 the government added NZ$33.5 million in subsidies and US$10 million toward marketing the country (RNZ, October 27, 2010). It also promised a law change on film workers.
Parliament passed that change under urgency two days later. It set how film work separates employees from contractors. Opposition MPs called the process undemocratic and rushed (RNZ, October 29, 2010).
Ten years on, the same story played out in reverse. In August 2021, Amazon moved its Lord of the Rings series to the UK after one season shot in New Zealand. Government figures put season one spending at US$465 million or more, with 1,200 direct and 700 indirect jobs (CBC News, August 13, 2021). The economic development minister put it plainly: "The international film sector is incredibly competitive and highly mobile."
The two big reports differ on the size of that series. CBC gave a rebate of at least US$92 million. 1News gave NZ$663.74 million in qualifying spending and about NZ$132 million in rebate (1News, August 2021). Much of the gap is the currency.
NZIER's view of the grant itself was positive. It counted NZ$127 million in screen grants tied to NZ$583 million in qualifying spending. Without the grant, it estimated, GDP would be NZ$176 million lower (NZIER). It did not work out a net return to taxpayers.
What it means for Newfoundland
Newfoundland and Labrador passed $1 billion in film and TV production spending in 2025. Activity in 2024 alone topped $87 million and supported nearly 1,500 full-time jobs (Government of Newfoundland and Labrador, September 2025).
The province already sells its screen credits to visitors. Its tourism site points people to Severance on the Bonavista Peninsula and Maudie in the Goulds (Newfoundland and Labrador Tourism). A May 2025 strategy for PictureNL says promoting the province's varied locations could bring both economic and cultural benefits (Olsberg SPI for PictureNL).
New Zealand suggests four lessons.
- A film alone rarely moves the numbers. The data only shifted when marketing was tied to the release.
- Benefits pool where something stays. Hobbiton kept its set and turned it into a business. Here, the outports and old houses on screen are already real places people can visit.
- Productions are mobile. Deals, subsidies and law changes can still lose a series to another country.
- The surest money is spent during the shoot. That same strategy notes some local productions source gear from other provinces (Olsberg SPI). Each piece found here keeps that spending at home.
Our view
Our view: film tourism is real, but it is slow, uneven and hard to plan around. New Zealand got its best results from one lasting attraction and a campaign built around a release, not from the films alone. For Newfoundland, the steadier win is making it easy to shoot here and spend here. That means local locations, local props and local makers, paid during the shoot. Owners can list a location or list their things, and crews can browse props and find locations. For the cost side of shooting on an island, read the island premium. For where Newfoundland has already played other places, see Newfoundland on screen.
Quick answers
Did The Lord of the Rings increase tourism in New Zealand?
Not measurably on its own, according to a peer-reviewed study that found no significant effect on arrivals from the original trilogy. The Hobbit films, released with a national marketing campaign, added an estimated 214,811 visitors in 2013 and 2014 (Li and others).
How many people visit Hobbiton each year?
Hobbiton expected about 570,000 visitors in its 2024 season, up from 530,000 the season before, with about 85% from overseas (Cambridge News, June 2024).
What did New Zealand pay to keep The Hobbit?
In 2010 the government added NZ$33.5 million in subsidies and US$10 million for marketing. It also promised a law change on film workers (RNZ, October 2010).
Could film tourism work in Newfoundland?
It can help, but New Zealand shows it works best alongside marketing and a lasting attraction. Newfoundland and Labrador Tourism already points visitors to places like the Bonavista Peninsula, where Severance filmed (Newfoundland and Labrador Tourism).
Sources
- Li, Li, Song, Lundberg and Shen, The Economic Impact of On-Screen Tourism (Tourism Management), Leeds Beckett University repository: No significant arrivals effect from The Lord of the Rings; Hobbit trilogy added 214,811 visitors, US$771.8 million in receipts, US$186 million in welfare, and crowding out in other industries.
- NZIER, The economic contribution of the screen industry (November 2017): Matamata-Piako visitor spending, Hobbit gains in NZ dollars, and screen grant figures.
- Tourism New Zealand release via Scoop (March 21, 2014): 14% of holiday visitors said The Hobbit was a factor, with shares by market.
- RNZ, Hobbit films staying in NZ (October 27, 2010): Extra NZ$33.5 million subsidy, US$10 million marketing, and the promised law change.
- RNZ, Hobbit labour law passed under urgency (October 29, 2010): Law on film workers passed under urgency, and opposition criticism.
- CBC News, Amazon moves Lord of the Rings series to Britain (August 13, 2021): Season one spend, jobs, US$92 million rebate and the minister's quote.
- 1News, NZ won't support Lord of Rings TV series after move to UK (August 2021): NZ$663.74 million qualifying spend and about NZ$132 million rebate.
- Cambridge News, Our precious (June 5, 2024): Hobbiton visitors, overseas share, staff, history and pandemic layoffs.
- Hobbiton Movie Set release via Scoop (April 30, 2025): 44 permanent hobbit holes and Guinness World Records title.
- NZ Herald, Inside a hobbit home (December 2, 2023): Set covers 5 hectares of a 500-hectare farm.
- Government of Newfoundland and Labrador (September 10, 2025): $1 billion production milestone, $87 million in 2024 and nearly 1,500 jobs.
- Newfoundland and Labrador Tourism, Filmed here: Province promotes screen locations such as Severance on the Bonavista Peninsula and Maudie in the Goulds.
- Olsberg SPI for PictureNL, strategy final report (May 2025): Promoting locations for economic and cultural benefit; some productions source gear from other provinces.